Skip to content

Votto: Trout 'ruined' conversation for MLB's best player

Joe Robbins / Getty Images Sport / Getty

Five or six years ago, Joey Votto - the Cincinnati Reds' born-to-hit first baseman - could have been considered the best player in Major League Baseball.

Then Mike Trout came along and ruined that.

Ahead of Sunday's regular-season finale, Votto - who boasts a career .425 OBP and remains a dark-horse candidate for the 2016 National League MVP award - lamented how Trout's unrivaled abilities have pretty much stifled any debate as to who's the best baseball player on the planet.

"Personally, until Trout came into the league, I thought every year that I would be in the conversation for best player in the game and he f----d that up for everybody. Babe Ruth and Ted Williams included," Votto told Zach Buchanan of the Cincinnati Enquirer. "He's ruining it for everyone."

Votto isn't wrong. Since his 2012 rookie season, Trout is without parallel, compiling nearly 15 more WAR over that span than the next-most valuable player. Despite earning just one MVP award in his first four seasons, Trout has hit .310/.410/.564 while averaging 33 homers and 28 stolen bases per year since becoming a full-time player, and has been the game's best offensive player after adjusting for park effects and his league's run-scoring environment (171 wRC+).

WAR leaders, 2012-2016

Name WAR wRC+ OBP HR DRS
Mike Trout 46.9 171 .410 163 7
Josh Donaldson 32 141 .367 140 49
Andrew McCutchen 28.7 147 .390 124 -49
Miguel Cabrera 28.3 165 .406 169 -26
Adrian Beltre 28.2 132 .362 135 50
Buster Posey 27.6 139 .376 94 27
Robinson Cano 26.8 137 .366 134 23
Paul Goldschmidt 25.7 147 .402 132 38
Joey Votto 25.3 162 .443 102 12
Manny Machado 23 118 .333 105 75

And, as Votto noted, Trout has no apt historical comparison, either. No player in history has compiled more WAR through his age-24 season than Trout, who, in 2016, posted a new career high in on-base percentage (.439) and walk-to-strikeout ratio (0.83).

All-time WAR leaders, through age-24 season

Name WAR wRC+ HR ISO SB
Mike Trout 47.6 167 168 .251 142
Ty Cobb 47.2 172 36 .143 337
Mickey Mantle 41.1 164 173 .252 43
Mel Ott 38.6 150 176 .233 38
Jimmie Foxx 37.4 164 174 .289 29
Ted Williams 36.4 185 127 .286 11

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox