MLB Power Rankings: How teams stack up halfway through offseason

Welcome to the second edition of theScore's MLB Power Rankings for the offseason where we look at each club after the winter meetings. Odds courtesy theScore Bet.

Jump to:
ARI | ATH I ATL | BAL | BOS | CHC | CWS | CIN | CLE | COL | DET | HOU | KC | LAA | LAD | MIA | MIL | MIN | NYM | NYY | PHI | PIT | SD | SF | SEA | STL | TB | TEX | TOR | WSH

1. Los Angeles Dodgers

Previous: 1
World Series odds: +375

The Dodgers took care of their biggest piece of business early, bringing in Blake Snell on a five-year, $182-million contract. The rotation features arguably four of the top 20 starters in MLB with Snell, Tyler Glasnow, Shohei Ohtani, and Yoshinobu Yamamoto. Michael Conforto could thrive hitting in a star-studded lineup. It remains to be seen if the Dodgers will find a way to bring back fan favorite Teoscar Hernández.

2. New York Mets

Previous: 6 ⬆️
World Series odds: +750

The Mets made this winter's biggest splash when they lured Juan Soto away from the rival Yankees with a record $765-million contract. It's a huge deal for a franchise that's long played second fiddle in its own town and improves the team immediately. But the Mets can't be done yet. They still have big holes to fill in the corner infield spots and could use some more pitching even after signing a somewhat confusing combination of Clay Holmes, Frankie Montas, and Griffin Canning.

3. New York Yankees

Previous: 4 ⬆️
World Series odds: +750

The Yankees took the sting out of losing Soto by spending their money elsewhere. Signing Max Fried to a massive eight-year deal made it possible to trade Nestor Cortes Jr. for a substantial bullpen upgrade in Devin Williams. Brian Cashman and Co. then traded for former MVP Cody Bellinger to lengthen a lineup that could still add more pieces at first and third base before the winter is over.

4. Philadelphia Phillies

Previous: 2 ⬇️
World Series odds: +1200

It's been a quiet offseason for the Phillies, who already possess a roster capable of winning now. Dave Dombrowski shored up the bullpen by adding former Blue Jays closer Jordan Romano and has been fielding calls about third baseman Alec Bohm. Manager Rob Thomson said the Phillies don't intend to trade Bohm despite interest in the young All-Star.

5. San Diego Padres

Previous: 3 ⬇️
World Series odds: +1500

The Padres have done next to nothing to improve this offseason after taking the World Series champion Dodgers to the brink in the playoffs. San Diego has reportedly fielded calls for Dylan Cease and talked about trading batting champ Luis Arráez to free up payroll for other moves. They've also been connected to Japanese pitching phenom Roki Sasaki and veteran third baseman Nolan Arenado.

6. Atlanta Braves

Previous: 5 ⬇️
World Series odds: +850

The Braves kicked off the offseason by trading Jorge Soler and haven't done anything since. The front office seems to be banking on better health and bounce-back performances in 2025, which makes sense given how stacked this team is on paper. Adding a steady back-of-the-rotation starter or two would provide some much-needed insulation in case Spencer Strider suffers any setbacks in his recovery.

7. Baltimore Orioles

Previous: 8 ⬆️
World Series odds: +1200

There's new ownership in Baltimore, but we're not witnessing the big spending we hoped to see by now. While it's understandable Mike Elias wants to make sure there's payroll room down the road to lock up the young core, now is the time to spend with so many players still under pre-arbitration deals. The additions of Tyler O'Neill, Gary Sánchez, and Tomoyuki Sugano are great supplemental moves, but the Orioles still need to add a couple real difference-makers.

8. Houston Astros

Previous: 7 ⬇️
World Series odds: +1200

It's hard to believe the Astros still fancy themselves contenders considering their offseason so far. Instead of improving, they traded star outfielder Kyle Tucker and watched their big trade-deadline acquisition, Yusei Kikuchi, sign elsewhere. That said, the Astros, as presently constructed, aren't a bad team. Isaac Paredes, acquired for Tucker, is a great fit for Daikin Park, and there's still a possibility that they either re-sign Alex Bregman or trade for help. There's a chance this offseason can be salvaged.

9. Boston Red Sox

Previous: 14 ⬆️
World Series odds: +3000

Boston made its biggest splash in years by landing Garrett Crochet from the White Sox. Crochet is one of the league's elite starters and gives the Red Sox a long-desired ace. It's not a trade without risk, as Crochet has only thrown 219 MLB innings and will now feel the pressure of playing in a competitive market. Craig Breslow has plenty of payroll flexibility, and he should use that to add several more impact players. Another starter, some pieces for the back end of the bullpen, and a right-hander power bat are still needed.

10. Milwaukee Brewers

Previous: 10
World Series odds: +4000

The Brewers have no qualms about trading stars. Milwaukee has dealt Devin Williams, Corbin Burnes, and Josh Hader in three consecutive seasons. The Brew Crew also enter 2025 without Willy Adames, who left via free agency after enjoying a career year. Cortes is a solid veteran addition to a rotation that needs to eat innings. Milwaukee remains positioned to contend thanks to a blossoming young roster in a weak NL Central, but losing the two stars hasn't improved its chances.

11. Texas Rangers

Previous: 15 ⬆️
World Series odds: +2500

The Rangers have quietly had a good offseason. Bringing back Nathan Eovaldi on a three-year, $75-million contract was expensive but smart. New acquisition Kyle Higashioka should form a solid catching tandem with Jonah Heim. Trading for Jake Burger was also an interesting move after he hit 29 home runs on a dreadful Marlins team last year and 34 in 2023. He could be even more productive in a better situation.

12. Arizona Diamondbacks

Previous: 9 ⬇️
World Series odds: +3000

Arizona's been incredibly quiet this winter. The only addition thus far was reliever Seth Martinez, who was claimed from Houston in November. It's a bit odd that the D-Backs, who surprisingly won a pennant in 2023 and only missed this year's playoffs because of a tiebreaker, aren't being more aggressive because the seeds for success are here. Maybe it won't be a marquee free agent, but it's reasonable to expect they'll do something bigger than a waiver claim before spring training.

13. Cleveland Guardians

Previous: 13
World Series odds: +2500

The Guardians brought back former Cy Young winner Shane Bieber and veteran catcher Austin Hedges, but their biggest offseason move has been trading second baseman Andrés Giménez to the Blue Jays, which freed up $96.5 million in payroll over the next six years. The return, Spencer Horowitz, was then shipped to the Pirates for Luis L. Ortiz, whose intriguing arm could slot into Cleveland's rotation immediately.

14. Chicago Cubs

Previous: 19 ⬆️
World Series odds: +3000

The Cubs took a big swing, landing impending free agent Tucker in a blockbuster trade. It's a worthwhile gamble for Chicago. The Cubs have stagnated over the past few seasons, and the price they paid for a player of Tucker's caliber, even if only for one year, wasn't outlandish. The trade will look even better if he can be locked up long term. It will be interesting to see how Chicago spends the money it cleared out by trading Bellinger.

15. Seattle Mariners

Previous: 11 ⬇️
World Series odds: +2500

The Mariners haven't made a big move yet, but it feels like they're lying in wait. They desperately need to add at least one big bat, and they have a surplus of excellent starting pitchers to deal from. Teams are reportedly calling about Luis Castillo, and while he'd certainly be missed, they'd probably jump at the right trade if it presents itself.

16. Detroit Tigers

Previous: 12 ⬇️
World Series odds: +4000

The Tigers have been quiet after sneaking into the playoffs on a blazing end-of-season run. Alex Cobb, their lone signing, is a solid starting pitcher who struggles to stay healthy. The front office should be looking to boost the lineup with a veteran bat, and Bregman would be an ideal fit if the club is willing to pay up. His talent and championship pedigree could help Detroit take the next step into becoming a perennial contender.

17. Kansas City Royals

Previous: 17
World Series odds: +4000

The Royals handled some business early on when they re-signed Michael Wacha to a three-year, $51-million deal after he pitched well last season. Kansas City then found a leadoff hitter to bat in front of Bobby Witt Jr. by acquiring Jonathan India from the Reds for pitcher Brady Singer. Otherwise, the Royals are bringing back much of the same roster that reached the playoffs last season after improving by 30 wins.

18. San Francisco Giants

Previous: 20 ⬆️
World Series odds: +5000

New president of baseball operations Buster Posey didn't wait long to make a splash, inking Adames to a franchise-record seven-year, $182-million deal. Adames makes the Giants better, but much more is needed to make them a true threat in the NL West. The club's taken some hits this winter, most notably seeing Snell defect to the Dodgers. If Posey can lure Burnes to Oracle Park, this offseason suddenly looks a lot better. As it stands now, the team's ceiling seems low.

19. Tampa Bay Rays

Previous: 16 ⬇️
World Series odds: +5000

The Rays have mostly been in the news for stadium-related topics this winter, but the front office has been making baseball decisions as well. Tampa Bay traded Jose Siri to the Mets to avoid paying him $2.3 million in arbitration and used some of the saved money to sign Danny Jansen to a one-year deal. They also traded from a position of strength, dealing starting left-hander Jeffrey Springs to the Athletics in a five-player swap that netted them a big young arm in Joe Boyle.

20. Toronto Blue Jays

Previous: 21 ⬆️
World Series odds: +6000

The Blue Jays continue to prioritize run prevention, surprising many by acquiring Giménez from Cleveland. He's one of the game's premier defenders at second base and could slide over to shortstop if Bo Bichette is traded or leaves in free agency following the 2025 campaign. There are still major areas of weakness on the roster with the Blue Jays needing to add a power bat, a starting pitcher, and more bullpen help, even after adding Yimi García and Nick Sandlin.

21. Minnesota Twins

Previous: 18 ⬇️
World Series odds: +3000

Alex Kirilloff retiring is the biggest story of the Twins' offseason; they've been quiet as a mouse on the free-agent market. Fans hoping for some additions have to be feeling disappointed in their team's offseason business after watching a deflating second-half collapse. The Twins have some pieces but must improve to be a factor in the now surprisingly competitive AL Central.

22. St. Louis Cardinals

Previous: 22
World Series odds: +6000

The Cardinals have spent much of the winter subtracting payroll - declining options on Lance Lynn, Kyle Gibson, and Keynan Middleton - as they shift their focus toward youth. Much of the team's offseason noise has revolved around potentially trading Arenado, who seems destined to move in 2025 if St. Louis can find the right suitor to take on the remaining three years of his contract.

23. Cincinnati Reds

Previous: 23
World Series odds: +6000

So far, the Reds' biggest acquisition has been the shocking hire of manager Terry Francona. The future Hall of Famer's presence hasn't led to any major roster moves in Cincinnati, beyond trading India for Singer and keeping Nick Martinez after he accepted a qualifying offer. The Reds have some bright young talent, and they play in a winnable division. It's time to take advantage and make a real splash.

24. Athletics

Previous: 26 ⬆️
World Series odds: +15000

The Athletics stunned everyone when they signed Luis Severino to a franchise-record three-year, $67-million contract. They also made a savvy trade in acquiring Jeffrey Springs from the Tampa Bay Rays. While it's great to see the organization finally adding talent, the timing of these moves - right after the team left Oakland - is a tough pill for fans to swallow.

25. Pittsburgh Pirates

Previous: 24 ⬇️
World Series odds: +7500

The Pirates have mostly made depth moves this offseason, but they did reel in Horowitz. The 27-year-old could finally be the answer at first base after the spot has been a revolving door of veterans on one-year deals. Jared Jones and Mitch Keller reportedly landing on the trade block certainly opened some eyes, as both hurlers seemed like integral pieces in the rotation for years to come.

26. Los Angeles Angels

Previous: 27 ⬆️
World Series odds: +15000

Another offseason brings with it another series of head-scratchers. Signing a veteran starter like Kikuchi and trading for Soler are the kinds of moves contenders are supposed to make. But the Angels, while unquestionably better on paper, are still years away from competing for a playoff spot. The Halos remain one of MLB's most confusing and unpredictable organizations.

27. Washington Nationals

Previous: 25 ⬇️
World Series odds: +15000

So far, it's been crickets out of the nation's capital. Clearly, the Nationals are banking on their young core to take the next step together in 2025. That's a reasonable request, but they can't do it alone. Some veteran leadership would be a wise addition to the clubhouse. The Nats might want to think about overpaying now to lure someone like Pete Alonso the same way they did with Jayson Werth a decade ago.

28. Colorado Rockies

Previous: 28
World Series odds: +40000

The Rockies have made some low-risk moves to add veteran depth to the squad, but they've otherwise been quiet. Colorado spent a combined $8.5 million on catcher Jacob Stallings and infielders Thairo Estrada and Kyle Farmer. The moves won't move the needle much for a club that lost 101 games last season, but they should be quality clubhouse guys for youngsters Ezequiel Tovar, Brenton Doyle, Michael Toglia, and Nolan Jones to be around.

29. Miami Marlins

Previous: 29
World Series odds: +30000

The Marlins haven't done anything to even try and improve their prospects after a 100-loss campaign. In fact, they traded their leading home run hitter from last season in Burger. No player on the roster has hit more than 18 homers in an MLB season. Left-hander Jesús Luzardo also appears to be available in trade talks. Rookie manager Clayton McCullough's got his work cut out for him as this is a full teardown.

30. Chicago White Sox

Previous: 30
World Series odds: +40000

White Sox general manager Chris Getz fared well in moving Crochet, landing four prospects who immediately slotted into the top 15 in the club's farm system. The roster is still far and away the league's worst, but bringing in more prospects is the only path forward for climbing out of the basement.