Skip to content

Fantasy Closer Grid: Melancon's struggles intensify; Grilli perfect for Braves

Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports

Every week we'll look at each team's closing situation - who's in, who's out, who's next in line - and provide fantasy-related tidbits

AL East

Team Closer Next in line
Blue Jays Miguel Castro Brett Cecil/Roberto Osuna
Orioles Zach Britton Tommy Hunter/Darren O'Day
Rays Brad Boxberger Ernesto Frieri/Kevin Jepsen
Red Sox Koji Uehara Edward Mujica/Junichi Tazawa
Yankees Andrew Miller Dellin Betances

Closer DL: Jake McGee (Rays)

  • Miller appears to have a firm grip on the Yankees' closer's job - for now, at least. The lefty has collected all five saves with a whopping 13 strikeouts in 6 1/3 innings.
  • There's one less reliever battling for holds and save opportunities in Tampa Bay after Grant Balfour was designated for assignment this week. It remains Boxberger's gig until further notice.

AL Central

Team Closer Next in line
Indians Cody Allen Bryan Shaw
Royals Wade Davis Kelvin Herrera
Tigers Joakim Soria Al Alburquerque/Joba Chamberlain
Twins Glen Perkins Casey Fien
White Sox David Robertson Zach Duke

Closer DL: Greg Holland (Royals), Joe Nathan (Tigers)

  • Grab Herrera if he's available, at least while Holland's out with a pectoral strain. Davis is the guy to own, but Herrera could see ninth-inning action coming off a back-to-back, suspension notwithstanding.
  • Nathan is expected to reclaim the closer's role upon his return - which could come as early as Friday - despite Soria's 5-for-5 save success rate and 1.35 ERA since taking over stopper duties. Both should be owned until the situation becomes clearer.

AL West

Team Closer Next in line
Angels Huston Street Joe Smith/Fernando Salas
Astros Luke Gregerson Chad Qualls/Pat Neshek
Athletics Tyler Clippard Dan Otero/Eric O'Flaherty
Mariners Fernando Rodney Danny Farquhar
Rangers Neftali Feliz Shawn Tolleson/Keone Kela

Closer DL: Sean Doolittle (Athletics)

  • Rodney has settled down after imploding last week, pitching two scoreless innings with four strikeouts and no walks over his last two appearances. Nothing to see here.
  • Doolittle's scheduled to throw off flat ground Friday, so the Oakland situation could soon require monitoring. Clippard's shown shaky command thus far and hasn't solidified the job in Doolittle's absence.

NL East

Team Closer Next in line
Braves Jason Grilli Jim Johnson/Luis Avilan
Marlins Steve Cishek Mike Dunn/A.J. Ramos
Mets Jeurys Familia Carlos Torres
Nationals Drew Storen Blake Treinen/Matt Thornton
Phillies Jonathan Papelbon Ken Giles

Closer DL: Jenrry Mejia - suspended (Mets), Bobby Parnell (Mets)

  • Grilli's a perfect 6-for-6 in the post-Craig Kimbrel era in Atlanta, though his setup man, Johnson, has been underwhelming. Keep an eye on right-hander Cody Martin as a sleeper late-inning option this season, as the rookie has an impressive 13 strikeouts to two walks thus far.

NL Central

Team Closer Next in line
Brewers Francisco Rodriguez Jonathan Broxton
Cardinals Trevor Rosenthal Jordan Walden
Cubs Hector Rondon Pedro Strop/Jason Motte
Pirates Mark Melancon Tony Watson
Reds Aroldis Chapman Kevin Gregg/Jumbo Diaz
  • After pitching with diminished velocity last week, Melancon's struggles are starting to show up in the win-loss column. The right-hander blew his first save of the year Tuesday and now sports an uninspiring 8.53 ERA across six appearances. Pick up Watson if you're a Melancon owner with a roster spot to spare.

NL West

Team Closer Next in line
Diamondbacks Addison Reed Brad Ziegler
Dodgers Joel Peralta J.P. Howell/Chris Hatcher
Giants Santiago Casilla Sergio Romo
Padres Craig Kimbrel Joaquin Benoit
Rockies Adam Ottavino Rafael Betancourt/LaTroy Hawkins

Closer DL: Kenley Jansen (Dodgers)

  • Hawkins' stock continues to drop after imploding Monday to up his ERA to 10.50 on the season, while Betancourt and his 10:1 strikeout-to-walk rate inches his way up the depth chart.
  • Jansen is getting closer to a return and could face live hitters as early as next week.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox