Skip to content

theScore's Week 5 Fantasy Hitter Power Rankings

Scott Halleran / Getty Images Sport / Getty

Here is the Week 5 edition of theScore's Fantasy Hitter Power Rankings, in which we list the top 40 hitters in fantasy baseball using standard 5x5 scoring (Value Based Ranks provided by FantasyPros; stats through Monday):

1. 2B Jose Altuve, Astros (LW: 1)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
1 .323 31 9 22 13

Altuve has a stranglehold on top spot after posting the best fantasy line over the last seven days (.417, 10 R, 2 HR, 8 RBIs, 4 SB). He's showing no signs of slowing, and he's on pace to post the first 30-HR/60-SB season ever.

2. 3B Nolan Arenado, Rockies (LW: 2)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
2 .310 27 12 29 0

Arenado had a quiet week by his standards (.296, 4 R, 1 HR, 4 RBIs), but his previous body of work was strong enough to keep him in the No. 2 spot. The gap between he and Altuve, however, is only growing larger.

3. 2B Robinson Cano, Mariners (LW: 35)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
3 .301 20 12 33 0

Cano has been the No. 1 fantasy option over the past 15 days, batting .400 over that stretch with 10 runs scored, six homers and 19 RBIs. He's having a career year so far, but owners shouldn't expect this pace to continue.

4. 1B Anthony Rizzo, Cubs (LW: 12)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
5 .270 26 10 28 2

The batting average had to climb eventually, and sure enough it has; Rizzo batted .417 over the past seven days, adding a pair of homers and eight runs scored. Health willing, he should score and drive in 100 runs with ease.

5. OF Bryce Harper, Nationals (LW: 4)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
4 .260 21 10 27 5

The walks are here: Harper drew as many free passes (15) as official at-bats over the previous week, and he was limited to a .200 average with one homer and three RBIs. He's still a beast, but that early-season surge is gone.

6. 3B/SS Manny Machado, Orioles (LW: 5)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
6 .350 24 9 22 0

Machado keeps on raking, and the dual-position eligibility strengthens his stock even more. He's still looking for his first stolen base of the season, but owners probably won't care as long as he's hitting .350.

7. OF Yoenis Cespedes, Mets (LW: 17)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
7 .300 19 11 31 0

Cespedes is showing last year's second half was no fluke, coming off a seven-day stretch in which he hit .333 with three homers, six RBIs and just two strikeouts. He's on track to finish as a top-5 fantasy outfielder.

8. SS Trevor Story, Rockies (LW: 7)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
8 .277 23 11 27 2

The strikeouts are a major concern, but there's no denying Story's talent. He went 11-for-30 last week with a homer, seven RBIs and a steal; and yes, he whiffed eight times, but owners will take this Ks with this kind of production.

9. 3B Josh Donaldson, Blue Jays (LW: 3)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
9 .268 31 9 21 2

Donaldson had seemingly been immune to the Blue Jays' offensive struggles, but they finally caught up with him last week (.167, 5 R, 0 HR, 0 RBIs, 1 SB). He'll bounce back for sure, but this takes the sheen off a blistering start.

10. OF Ryan Braun, Brewers (LW: 10)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
10 .363 19 7 24 2

Braun holds steady this week after hitting .333 with a pair of home runs over the previous seven days. Owners would undoubtedly like to see him run more, but in all other areas, he's delivering elite fantasy value.

11. 2B/3B Daniel Murphy, Nationals (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
11 .398 21 5 20 1

Murphy's ridiculous 2015 playoff run didn't lead to a major bump in his 2016 ADP; perhaps it should have. He leads the majors in hitting after posting a .448 mark last week, adding nine runs scored, three homers and seven RBIs.

12. OF Dexter Fowler, Cubs (LW: 8)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
12 .340 24 3 17 6

Fowler continues to tumble down the rankings, coming off a week in which he hit .273 with just three runs scored, two RBIs and a steal. The runs will keep him fantasy relevant, but he's not doing enough in the other categories.

13. OF Starling Marte, Pirates (LW: 9)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
13 .341 19 3 14 9

This is a tough break for Marte, who slips four spots despite hitting .409 with a pair of steals last week. His power game has stalled, as he has just one home run and three RBIs in the past 15 days. That hurts him in fantasy.

14. DH David Ortiz, Red Sox (LW: 27)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
15 .321 18 9 29 1

Red Sox fans are already hoping for one more year out of Ortiz - and fantasy owners may be wishing for the same thing soon enough. Ortiz is dangerous as ever, and posted a monster line last week (.333, 4 HR, 10 RBIs).

15. 2B Rougned Odor, Rangers (LW: 31)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
16 .298 24 7 21 4

Batting leadoff agrees with Odor, who has been a force since taking over for the ineffective Delino DeShields. Odor was a monster last week, batting .371 with eight runs scored, four homers and seven RBIs.

16. 1B/OF Mark Trumbo, Orioles (LW: 14)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
17 .325 16 9 24 1

That batting average refuses to fall, taking only a minor hit as Trumbo batted .305 last week with three homers and five RBIs. He remains one of the most consistent contributors in fantasy, though BA regression could be swift.

17. 2B Ian Kinsler, Tigers (LW: 16)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
14 .302 27 6 17 3

Kinsler gets a significant VBR boost thanks to his whopping 27 runs scored, but the batting average has slipped from near-.350 levels earlier this month. He's still a power/speed threat, however, and remains an elite 2B option.

18. 3B Nick Castellanos, Tigers (LW: 28)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
18 .380 14 6 26 1

No player in baseball hits the ball with less soft contact than Castellanos, whose 7.2-percent rate has played a major role in his absurd .455 BABIP. Neither rate is sustainable, but it doesn't have to be: He's still a stud.

19. SS Aledmys Diaz, Cardinals (LW: 13)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
19 .396 23 5 16 1

Diaz's batting average is still stratospheric thanks to a 7-for-19 showing last week. Runs aside, the rest of the numbers are lacking; he's also a good bet to lose some playing time, particularly when Jhonny Peralta returns.

20. OF Stephen Piscotty, Cardinals (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
20 .323 21 5 21 2

Piscotty skyrocketed his way onto the list with an impressive seven-day showing (.458, 4 R, 1 HR, 5 RBI, 1 SB). Just as commendable is his improved batting eye, as he has struck out just once in his last five games.

21. OF Mike Trout, Angels (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
21 .313 16 7 23 2

There he is! Trout didn't exactly light the world on fire last week (.316, 1 R, 1 HR, 5 RBIs) but with a .333 average and 15 RBIs over his last 15 days, he's finally showing the promise that made him the consensus No. 1 fantasy pick.

22. 1B Chris Carter, Brewers (LW: 32)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
22 .273 21 10 22 0

After slipping 10 spots last week, Carter returned to familiar territory after swatting three home runs and scoring six times in the past week. His average continues to tumble, but the power more than makes up for that.

23. OF Mookie Betts, Red Sox (LW: 6)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
23 .246 24 4 18 7

It was an ugly week for Betts, who careened down the rankings after batting a dismal .179 with four runs scored, one RBI and one steal in 28 at-bats. That said, he has the talent to rebound immediately.

24. SS Xander Bogaerts, Red Sox (LW: 21)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
24 .315 23 2 14 6

Bogaerts is closing on Betts in the rankings after hitting .345 with four runs scored, a home run, three RBIs and a steal last week. More than any player on this list, he's headed for a season just like the one he had in 2015.

25. 2B/SS Jean Segura, Diamondbacks (LW: 15)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
25 .341 18 5 16 4

While Segura continues to contribute in two areas - batting average and runs scored - the rest of the counting stat categories have stagnated. But owners can't complain, considering he was either a late pick or a waiver claim.

26. 3B Kris Bryant, Cubs (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
26 .299 23 5 20 1

As nice as it was to see Bryant put together an overall solid week (.333, 5 R, 1 HR, 4 RBI), it was the stolen base that stood out the most. Bryant had 13 a season ago, and owners would love to see a repeat of that in 2016.

27. 2B/OF Ben Zobrist, Cubs (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
27 .277 21 5 25 1

Zobrist owners are probably still in shock after the multi-talented-but-light-hitting veteran boasted a .364 average with four homers, 13 RBIs and seven runs scored last week. He could be in for a career year.

28. OF Giancarlo Stanton, Marlins (LW: 38)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
28 .250 17 10 24 0

The .238 batting average did him no favors last week, but Stanton moved up the list thanks to a pair of homers, four RBIs and five runs scored. He's doing exactly what fantasy owners should have expected of him.

29. OF Gregory Polanco, Pirates (LW: 23)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
30 .284 21 4 19 3

Polanco scuffled for the majority of last week, recording just four hits in 23 at-bats. He did have a home run and a steal, however, and he has shown enough proficiency in both categories to remain a top-30 fantasy hitting option.

30. OF Odubel Herrera, Phillies (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
29 .324 20 3 11 5

The few fantasy players yet to believe in Herrera may be converted soon enough. The unheralded Phillies outfielder batted .375 last week to move his average back above .320; he added a home run and a steal, as well.

31. OF Christian Yelich, Marlins (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
31 .333 20 4 16 2

Last week was a great one for Yelich (.308, 7 R, 3 HR, 7 RBI, 1 SB), and it was a long time coming for owners who patiently waited for his breakout. This could kick-start Yelich to a solid fantasy season; he certainly has the skill for it.

32. OF Gerardo Parra, Rockies (LW: 24)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
32 .298 18 3 19 5

Parra kept himself afloat by hitting .345 with four runs and five RBIs last week, but a big fat zero in the home run and stolen base departments was a letdown. He and his fantasy owners should see better results this week.

33. OF Hunter Pence, Giants (LW: 26)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
33 .294 19 5 25 0

Pence was just okay last week, batting .304 while scoring twice and driving in three runs. Those who invested a draft pick in him are waiting for a home-run boost, but everything else has been solid so far.

34. SS Eugenio Suarez, Reds (LW: 19)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
34 .246 18 6 18 4

No player on this list has had a worse May than Suarez, who is batting just .172 with one homer, three RBIs and four runs scored this month. Nine of his 18 RBIs came in his first six games of the season. Sell him if you can.

35. 1B Eric Hosmer, Royals (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
35 .328 16 6 16 3

Hosmer climbs his way onto the list after having a productive seven-day stretch that saw him hit .286 with five runs scored, two homers and seven RBIs. The three steals through 31 games are a nice bonus.

36. SS Carlos Correa, Astros (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
36 .284 18 5 16 4

The trend arrow is once again pointing up for Correa after a miserable three-week stretch. Correa batted .370 with two homers, seven RBIs, six runs and a steal last week; he's as streaky as they come, but he still has elite talent.

37. SS Francisco Lindor, Indians (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
37 .313 19 2 12 5

While he may not hit 20 homers or drive in 100 runs, Lindor is proving to be a valuable major-league and fantasy contributor. He batted .370 with a homer and a steal last week, maintaining elite value at his position.

38. OF Matt Kemp, Padres (LW: 30)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
38 .279 15 8 23 0

The yo-yo experience of owning Kemp in fantasy took another downward turn last week as the Padres star hit just 5-for-23 with one homer - accounting for his only run - and two RBIs. Despite the slump, he's a sell-high candidate.

39. 1B/OF Wil Myers, Padres (LW: 25)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
39 .281 17 6 16 3

Myers also had a rough week for San Diego, batting .167 with a homer, two runs scored and three RBIs. Fantasy owners shouldn't be worried, though; if he can stay healthy, Myers will end up being a steal by season's end.

40. 1B Brandon Belt, Giants (LW: --)

VBR AVG R HR RBI SB
40 .327 18 4 21 0

Belt snags the last spot in the rankings after going 9-for-23 over the past week. While he added just three runs scored, one homer and two RBIs, his batting average should make him a hot fantasy commodity all season long.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox