Find positional rankings, additional analysis, and subscribe to push notifications in the NFL Fantasy News section.
Given the rate at which injuries strike the running back position, knowing who's next in line for carries is critical for fantasy owners.
Not all backup rushers are created equal, and though the league-winning potential of players like Kareem Hunt and Tony Pollard may appear obvious, many second-string ball carriers don't get the respect they deserve in fantasy drafts.
Here's how we're ranking the top reserve tailbacks, broken down into tiers:
Elite backup options
Rk
Backup
Team
1
AJ Dillon
GB
2
Kareem Hunt
CLE
3
Tony Pollard
DAL
RB1 upside if the starter is sidelined
Stuck behind a more talented back
Will offer RB2/flex value some weeks, even as a backup
Proven short-term starters
Rk
Backup
Team
4
Alexander Mattison
MIN
5
Darrell Henderson
LAR
RB1 upside if the starter is sidelined
Stuck behind a more talented back
Won't offer enough production unless the lead back gets injured
Chance to carve out bigger role
Rk
Backup
Team
6
Rhamondre Stevenson
NE
7
James Cook
BUF
Could rise to the top of the depth chart during the season
Top-20 upside if the starter is sidelined
Can provide flex value some weeks, even as a backup
High upside if healthy
Rk
Backup
Team
8
Melvin Gordon
DEN
9
James Robinson
JAX
10
Ken Walker III
SEA
11
Gus Edwards
BAL
Currently recovering from an injury
Behind a RB with high draft capital
Can provide flex value some weeks, even as a backup
Tons of potential
Rk
Backup
Team
12
Kenneth Gainwell
PHI
13
Michael Carter
NYJ
14
Khalil Herbert
CHI
Top-24 upside if the starter is sidelined
Should have a notable role behind lead back
Can provide flex value some weeks, even as a backup
Unproven but enticing
Rk
Backup
Team
15
Rachaad White
TB
16
Isiah Pacheco
KC
17
Tyler Allgeier
ATL
18
Tyrion Davis-Price
SF
19
Zamir White
LV
20
Eno Benjamin
ARI
2022 role yet to be determined
Top-30 upside if starting at any point
Workload questions due to crowded backfields
PPR specialists
Rk
Backup
Team
21
Nyheim Hines
IND
22
J.D. McKissic
WAS
Limited upside as a fantasy insurance policy
Unlikely to serve as a workhorse if the starter is injured
Can offer flex value in PPR formats, even as a backup
Volume-dependent veterans
Rk
Backup
Team
23
Jamaal Williams
DET
24
Mark Ingram
NO
25
D'Onta Foreman
CAR
26
Dontrell Hilliard
TEN
27
Joshua Kelley
LAC
Veteran backup
Some doubt surrounding the ability to produce if called upon
Would need the majority of touches to be fantasy relevant
Unclear situations
Rk
Backup
Team
28
Sony Michel/Raheem Mostert
MIA
29
Samaje Perine/Chris Evans
CIN
30
Marlon Mack/Rex Burkhead
HOU
31
Benny Snell/Jaylen Warren
PIT
32
Matt Breida/Gary Brightwell/Jashaun Corbin/Antonio Williams
NYG
Upside if a clear backup emerges and the starter is injured
Value limited by the possibility of a committee replacement scenario
Players to draft as bench stashes in final rounds
Deep targets
Backup
Team
D'Ernest Johnson
CLE
Isaiah Spiller
LAC
Ameer Abdullah
LV
Jerick McKinnon
KC
Damien Williams
ATL
Tyler Badie
BAL
Mike Davis
BAL
Jeff Wilson Jr.
SF
Phillip Lindsay
IND
Ty Montgomery
NE
Travis Homer
SEA
Zack Moss
BUF
Kyren Williams
LAR
Long shots with intriguing upside if injuries hit their backfield
Have the skills to produce over short stretches
Watchlist candidates who could turn into key waiver wire pickups